Searching for the best kettle grill pizza insert can feel overwhelming given the variety of options. The KettlePizza Basic 22.5 stands out for its simplicity and affordability, making it ideal for casual cooks. For those seeking a more versatile setup, the KettlePizza Pro 22 Kit offers professional-grade features for serious pizza lovers. The main tradeoffs often come down to ease of use versus customization potential, with some inserts designed for quick setup while others offer more control over cooking conditions. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown of each option to find the best fit for your outdoor pizza ambitions.
Get kitchen gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The best overall pick balances ease of installation with consistent high-quality results, like the KettlePizza Basic 22.5.
- Premium options such as the KettlePizza Pro 22 Kit provide advanced features but come at a higher price and complexity.
- Material quality varies, with stainless steel models offering better durability but sometimes at a premium cost.
- Many inserts are compatible with specific kettle sizes; choosing the right fit is crucial for performance.
- Ease of use and installation can significantly impact your overall satisfaction, especially for beginners.
| KettlePizza Basic 22.5 – Pizza Oven Kit for 22.5 Inch Kettle Grills |  | Best Overall for Versatile Conversion | Material: 20 gauge, 304 grade stainless steel | Compatibility: 22.5 inch kettle grills (e.g., Weber One Touch Gold or Silver) | Made in: USA | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KettlePizza Pizza Oven Kit for 26 Inch Weber Kettle |  | Best for Weber 26-inch Grill Owners | Compatibility: 26 inch Weber kettle grills | Includes: aluminum pan, 15″ cordierite stone, metal peel | Material: American Made stainless steel | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KettlePizza Basic Charcoal Pizza Oven Kit for 26.75 Inch Weber Kettle Grill |  | Best for Larger Weber Kettles | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown | |||
| Kettle Pizza Serious Eats Kit |  | Best for Versatile Pizza and Cooking Accessories | Compatibility: 22.5-inch charcoal grill | Includes: pan, wood peel, metal peel, Prograte with Tombstone & Baking Steel lid | Assembly: Some basic, no-tool needed | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Onlyfire Stainless Steel Pizza Ring Kit for Weber 22-Inch Kettle Charcoal Grill |  | Best for Authentic Woodfired Pizzas | Material: Stainless steel | Included: Pizza ring, 15″ pizza stone, pizza peel, support chips | Compatibility: Weber 22-inch kettle grills | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KettlePizza Pro 22 Kit – Outdoor Pizza Oven for 22.5 Inch Kettles |  | Best Overall for Serious Pizza Enthusiasts | Brand: Kettle Pizza | Size: 22.5 inches | Material: 304 stainless steel | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| KettlePizza ProGrate & Tombstone Combination Kit for 22.5″ Kettle Grills |  | Best for Easy Setup and Consistent Results | Compatibility: 22.5″ kettle grills with KettlePizza inserts | Material (Grate): 304 stainless steel | Material (Pizza Stone): Cordierite | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| kettle grill pizza insert | Compatibility | Material | Made in |
|---|---|---|---|
| KettlePizza Basic 22.5 | 22.5 inch kettle grills (e.g., Weber One Touch Gold or Silver) | 20 gauge, 304 grade stainless steel | USA |
| KettlePizza Pizza Oven Kit for | 26 inch Weber kettle grills | American Made stainless steel | — |
| KettlePizza Basic Charcoal Piz | — | — | — |
| Kettle Pizza Serious Eats Kit | 22.5-inch charcoal grill | — | USA |
| Onlyfire Stainless Steel Pizza | Weber 22-inch kettle grills | Stainless steel | — |
| KettlePizza Pro 22 Kit | Only fits 22.5-inch kettle grills | 304 stainless steel | USA |
| KettlePizza ProGrate & Tombsto | 22.5" kettle grills with KettlePizza inserts | — | USA |
More Details on Our Top Picks
KettlePizza Basic 22.5 – Pizza Oven Kit for 22.5 Inch Kettle Grills
This kit stands out for transforming standard 22.5-inch kettle grills into dedicated pizza ovens, allowing for stable heat retention without lid removal. Compared to the Onlyfire Stainless Steel Pizza Ring Kit, it offers a more durable stainless steel build and broader compatibility with various charcoal types. However, it requires additional accessories like a skillet for cooking other foods, which could be less convenient for those seeking an all-in-one solution. Its sturdy construction and straightforward design make it ideal for grill owners who want a reliable, versatile setup, but it’s limited to a specific grill size and needs some assembly.
Pros:- Transforms standard kettle grills into pizza ovens with stable heat
- Durable 20 gauge, 304-grade stainless steel construction
- Compatible with various charcoal or hardwood fuels
Cons:- Requires additional accessories like a skillet for other foods
- Limited to 22.5-inch kettle grills, reducing versatility
Best for: Grill owners seeking a durable, all-purpose pizza conversion kit for their 22.5-inch kettle grill
Not ideal for: Buyers wanting a fully integrated, all-in-one pizza oven without extra accessories or assembly
- Material:20 gauge, 304 grade stainless steel
- Compatibility:22.5 inch kettle grills (e.g., Weber One Touch Gold or Silver)
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“This pick is best for those who want a sturdy, versatile pizza setup on their 22.5-inch kettle grill, willing to handle some assembly and extra accessories.”
KettlePizza Pizza Oven Kit for 26 Inch Weber Kettle
This kit makes it straightforward to convert a 26-inch Weber kettle into a pizza oven with all necessary accessories included, such as a stone, peel, and aluminum pan. When compared to the KettlePizza Basic Charcoal Pizza Oven Kit, it offers more comprehensive accessories, making setup easier for Weber users. The main tradeoff is that it’s limited to Weber’s 26-inch models and requires some initial setup, which might be less appealing to those wanting a simple plug-and-play solution. It’s ideal for Weber fans who want a complete package for outdoor pizza baking, but it doesn’t work with non-Weber grills or other sizes.
Pros:- Easy conversion for Weber 26-inch kettles
- Includes all necessary accessories for baking pizza
- Made from durable American stainless steel
Cons:- Requires a Weber grill (not compatible with other brands)
- Some assembly required, not a fully ready-to-use solution
Best for: Weber grill owners looking for an all-in-one, easy-to-use pizza conversion kit for their 26-inch kettle
Not ideal for: Owners of non-Weber or smaller grills seeking a more universal or less specific solution
- Compatibility:26 inch Weber kettle grills
- Includes:aluminum pan, 15″ cordierite stone, metal peel
- Material:American Made stainless steel
Our verdict“Best suited for Weber 26-inch grill owners wanting a complete, straightforward pizza setup with all accessories included.”
KettlePizza Basic Charcoal Pizza Oven Kit for 26.75 Inch Weber Kettle Grill
This kit offers a straightforward way to turn a 26.75-inch Weber Kettle into a pizza oven, perfect for those with larger grills wanting authentic outdoor pizza. Unlike the KettlePizza Basic 22.5, it caters to bigger grills but is limited strictly to pizza baking. Its simplicity is a plus for users wanting quick setup and outdoor-style pies, but it doesn’t include additional accessories or versatility for other cooking styles. If your grill size matches, this kit provides a reliable, easy-to-install option for outdoor pizza nights.
Pros:- Transforms large Weber Kettles into pizza ovens
- Easy installation and use
- Designed specifically for outdoor wood-fired style pizzas
Cons:- Limited to 26.75-inch Weber Kettles, no broader compatibility
- Focused solely on pizza baking, no multi-food versatility
Best for: Owners of 26.75-inch Weber Kettles who want a simple, dedicated pizza oven solution
Not ideal for: Those with smaller grills or seeking multi-purpose outdoor cooking setups
Our verdict“Ideal for Weber 26.75-inch grill owners seeking a dedicated, straightforward outdoor pizza oven.”
Kettle Pizza Serious Eats Kit
This kit stands out for offering multiple accessories, including pans and a Prograte with a baking steel lid, making it more versatile than many single-purpose options like the Onlyfire Stainless Steel Pizza Ring Kit. It’s designed specifically for 22.5-inch charcoal grills and features easy assembly with no tools needed, but its limited size compatibility might be a drawback for owners of larger grills. While it offers a more comprehensive outdoor cooking experience, beginners may find the assembly slightly challenging, and it’s primarily suited for dedicated pizza baking rather than multi-function grilling.
Pros:- Includes multiple accessories like pans and baking steel
- Easy to assemble without tools
- Made in the USA with patents pending
Cons:- Limited to 22.5-inch grills, restricting broader use
- Assembly may be tricky for complete beginners
Best for: Enthusiasts wanting a versatile, multi-accessory outdoor pizza setup for 22.5-inch grills
Not ideal for: Owners of larger grills or those seeking a simple, minimal setup for occasional pizza baking
- Compatibility:22.5-inch charcoal grill
- Includes:pan, wood peel, metal peel, Prograte with Tombstone & Baking Steel lid
- Assembly:Some basic, no-tool needed
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“Best for those who want a multi-functional, easy-to-assemble pizza kit with additional accessories for 22.5-inch grills.”
Onlyfire Stainless Steel Pizza Ring Kit for Weber 22-Inch Kettle Charcoal Grill
This kit excels at turning a Weber 22-inch kettle into an authentic pizza oven, thanks to its stainless steel ring, pizza stone, and support chips. Compared to the KettlePizza Basic 22.5 kit, it emphasizes maintaining consistent heat and providing a viewing window for monitoring the pizza, which can improve results for home chefs. However, it’s limited to specific grill sizes and not compatible with Weber Smokey Mountain models, which could be restrictive. It also relies solely on charcoal or hardwood, making it less suitable for gas grill owners but perfect for purists demanding woodfired flavors.
Pros:- Transforms Weber 22-inch kettles into pizza ovens
- Includes pizza stone, peel, and support chips for authentic results
- Maintains consistent heat and offers a viewing window
Cons:- Not compatible with Weber Smokey Mountain or other grills
- Requires charcoal or hardwood for flavor, limiting options
Best for: Home chefs with Weber 22-inch kettles seeking authentic, woodfired-style pizzas with monitoring features
Not ideal for: Owners of larger grills or gas-powered setups who want more flexibility or multi-purpose use
- Material:Stainless steel
- Included:Pizza ring, 15″ pizza stone, pizza peel, support chips
- Compatibility:Weber 22-inch kettle grills
- Patent Number:U.S. Patent No.10,405,699
Our verdict“Ideal for Weber 22-inch kettle owners who want to produce authentic, woodfired pizzas with monitoring capabilities.”
KettlePizza Pro 22 Kit – Outdoor Pizza Oven for 22.5 Inch Kettles
The KettlePizza Pro 22 Kit stands out for transforming a standard 22.5-inch kettle grill into a high-performance, wood-fired pizza oven, making it a top choice for dedicated outdoor pizza makers. Unlike the KettlePizza Basic 22.5, which offers a simpler setup, this kit includes a thick Tombstone stone, firebox, and a stainless steel ProGrate that enable better heat retention and more consistent baking. Its side access and drop slots facilitate quick refueling, mimicking a traditional wood-fired oven experience. However, its exclusivity to 22.5-inch grills and the need for assembly without tools are limitations for those with different grill sizes or limited DIY skills. This kit’s durability and made-in-USA quality justify its higher price for users seeking authentic, high-temperature pizza cooking at home.
Pros:- Transforms a standard kettle into a wood-fired pizza oven
- Includes high-quality components like a Tombstone stone and firebox for superior heat retention
- Easy refueling with side access and drop slots
Cons:- Limited to 22.5-inch kettle grills, reducing versatility
- Assembly required without included tools, which may be challenging for some users
- Higher price point compared to simpler inserts
Best for: Dedicated outdoor cooking enthusiasts who want a professional-quality pizza oven setup on their 22.5-inch kettle grill
Not ideal for: Casual grill owners or those with different-sized kettles, as this kit is specifically designed for 22.5-inch models and requires assembly
- Brand:Kettle Pizza
- Size:22.5 inches
- Material:304 stainless steel
- Included Items:ProGrate, Tombstone, firebox, aluminum peel, pizza pan, thermometer, hardware
- Compatibility:Only fits 22.5-inch kettle grills
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“This kit is best suited for serious outdoor pizza lovers who want an authentic wood-fired experience on a dedicated 22.5-inch kettle grill.”
KettlePizza ProGrate & Tombstone Combination Kit for 22.5″ Kettle Grills
The KettlePizza ProGrate & Tombstone Kit offers a straightforward way to upgrade a compatible 22.5-inch kettle grill with a reliable cooking surface and pizza stone, making it ideal for those seeking ease and consistent results. Compared to the KettlePizza Pro 22 Kit, which bundles more components and a full setup, this combination focuses on creating a superior cooking surface with a durable stainless steel grate and a 5/8-inch cordierite pizza stone that promotes even heat circulation. It requires the KettlePizza insert for installation, which might add complexity for some, and the weight of the stone could be a concern for handling. While it doesn’t include the firebox or side refueling features of the Pro 22 Kit, its simplicity and focus on heat distribution make it well-suited for home cooks who prioritize reliable, even pizzas without a full oven setup.
Pros:- Easily installs on compatible 22.5-inch kettle grills
- Stainless steel grate offers durability and better heat retention
- Cordierite pizza stone provides even cooking and excellent crust development
Cons:- Requires KettlePizza insert for installation, adding an extra step
- Heavy to handle due to the thick pizza stone
- Limited to 22.5-inch kettles, reducing flexibility
Best for: Home cooks who already own a KettlePizza insert and want an easy-to-install, durable cooking surface for consistent pizza results
Not ideal for: Users without a KettlePizza insert or those seeking a complete oven kit with firebox and refueling features
- Compatibility:22.5″ kettle grills with KettlePizza inserts
- Material (Grate):304 stainless steel
- Material (Pizza Stone):Cordierite
- Pizza Stone Thickness:5/8″
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“This kit makes a practical upgrade for those with a KettlePizza insert seeking improved heat circulation and consistent pizza quality.”
How We Picked
These products were evaluated based on their build quality, ease of installation, heat retention, and compatibility with popular kettle sizes. We prioritized models that offer consistent heat distribution for evenly cooked pizzas, as well as those that are easy to set up and clean. Cost-effectiveness was also a key factor, ensuring that both entry-level and advanced cooks can find suitable options. Our rankings reflect a balance between performance, value, and user flexibility, helping different types of buyers find the best fit for their needs.Factors to Consider When Choosing Kettle Grill Pizza Insert
Choosing the right kettle grill pizza insert involves more than just price. Consider your cooking style, experience level, and the size of your kettle grill. Some inserts are designed for quick assembly and beginner-friendly use, while others offer more control and customization for seasoned outdoor chefs. Understanding these factors can help prevent common pitfalls like incompatible sizes or underwhelming heat retention. The following sections cover key considerations to guide your purchase decision.Size Compatibility
Ensuring your pizza insert fits your kettle grill is essential for effective heat transfer and stability. Most inserts are designed for specific kettle diameters, such as 22.5 inches or 26 inches. Using an ill-fitting insert can lead to uneven cooking or difficulty in installation. Always double-check your grill’s dimensions and compare them with the product specifications before buying, to avoid frustration and subpar results.
Material and Durability
The material of the insert impacts its lifespan and performance. Stainless steel models tend to resist rust and withstand high temperatures better than painted or coated options. However, they often come at a higher cost. Cheaper materials may be tempting but could warp or degrade over time, especially with frequent use. Weigh your budget against long-term durability for the best value.
Ease of Installation and Use
Some inserts are quick to set up and require minimal fuss, making them perfect for occasional cooks or beginners. Others might involve more assembly or adjustment but offer greater control over cooking conditions. Consider your comfort level and how often you plan to use the insert. An easier-to-install option might be more practical if you’re new to outdoor pizza making, while experienced users might prefer more sophisticated setups.
Heat Retention and Distribution
Consistent, high heat is key for great pizza crusts. Look for inserts that promote even heat circulation, often through well-designed domes or special airflow channels. Poor heat retention can result in uneven cooking, with burnt toppings or undercooked bases. Investing in a model with strong thermal performance can significantly improve your pizza outcomes, especially if you aim for restaurant-quality results.
Price and Value
Prices range from budget-friendly options to premium setups with extra features. While cheaper inserts can be sufficient for casual use, investing in a higher-quality model often pays off in durability, better heat control, and improved results. Consider how often you’ll use the insert and what features matter most to your cooking style. Balancing cost with expected performance helps ensure you get the best value for your investment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a standard kettle grill for pizza cooking without an insert?
Yes, you can cook pizza directly on a kettle grill without an insert by using a pizza stone placed on the grill grates. However, an insert specifically designed for pizza provides a more consistent heat environment, easier handling, and often better crust results. Inserts also help contain and direct heat more effectively, making your pizza cooking experience more predictable and manageable.
Are stainless steel pizza inserts worth the extra cost?
Stainless steel inserts tend to last longer and resist rust better than coated alternatives, which can justify the higher price for frequent use. They also often provide better heat conduction and more even cooking. However, if you only grill occasionally or are on a tight budget, a less expensive coated insert might suffice. Evaluate your cooking frequency and durability needs before choosing.
How do I clean and maintain my kettle grill pizza insert?
Most inserts can be cleaned with a wire brush after they cool down to remove any baked-on residue. For stainless steel models, mild soap and water are usually sufficient, and occasional seasoning can prevent sticking. Avoid harsh chemicals that could degrade the material. Proper maintenance extends the lifespan of the insert and keeps your pizzas tasting their best.
What size insert should I get for my kettle grill?
The size of the insert must match your kettle grill’s diameter—most common sizes are 22.5 inches and 26 inches. Using an insert that’s too small may lead to uneven heating, while one that’s too large won’t fit properly and could be unstable. Measure your grill accurately and stick to inserts designed for your specific size for optimal results.
Is it better to buy a complete pizza kit or just an insert?
Choosing between a complete pizza kit and just an insert depends on your needs and experience. A kit often includes the insert, tools, and accessories, making it easier for beginners to get started. If you’re already comfortable with outdoor grilling and only need the insert, purchasing just the component can save money and allow customization. Consider your skill level and what additional features you might need before deciding.
Conclusion
For casual cooks and those new to outdoor pizza, the KettlePizza Basic 22.5 offers straightforward performance at a reasonable price. Serious enthusiasts who want precise control and durability will find the KettlePizza Pro 22 Kit a worthy investment. If budget is a concern, the Onlyfire Stainless Steel Pizza Ring Kit provides good value with decent longevity. For those seeking a premium experience, the KettlePizza Serious Eats Kit delivers advanced features for consistent, restaurant-quality results. Ultimately, your choice should align with your grilling frequency, experience level, and specific performance priorities.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
