When searching for a pizza oven that can deliver the iconic, crispy, and foldable New York style slices, the key is choosing equipment that combines high heat, even cooking, and sufficient capacity. The BIG HORN 14-Inch Indoor Pizza Oven stands out as the best overall for its ability to reach 850°F, mimicking traditional pizzeria conditions. The Solo Stove Pi Prime offers portability and quick setup, making it ideal for outdoor use, while the Cuisinart Indoor Pizza Oven balances affordability with reliable performance. However, tradeoffs exist, such as size constraints or learning curve. Keep reading for a detailed comparison to help you find the perfect match for your home kitchen or outdoor setup.
Get kitchen gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- High temperature capability (up to 850°F) is essential to replicate authentic New York pizza crusts.
- Size and capacity vary; larger ovens typically produce more traditional slices but may require more space.
- Portable options excel for outdoor use but often sacrifice some temperature or capacity.
- Features like preset modes and PID control can simplify operation but add to the cost.
- Price ranges widely; investing in a higher-end model can significantly improve authenticity and durability.
| pizza oven for new york style | Power | Size |
|---|---|---|
| BIG HORN 14-Inch Indoor Pizza | 1800W | 14 inches |
| Solo Stove Pi Prime Propane Pi | — | 21 x 16 inches |
| 12-inch Electric Pizza Oven In | — | 12 inches |
| Cuisinart Indoor Pizza Oven | — | — |
| Chefman Indoor Pizza Oven | 1700 Watts | — |
| 13-in-1 Countertop Pizza Oven | 1700W | — |
| Electric Pizza Oven | — | — |
| Piezano XL 14" Electric Pizza | Electric | 14 inches |
More Details on Our Top Picks
BIG HORN 14-Inch Indoor Pizza Oven, 850°F Electric Countertop Pizza Oven
The BIG HORN 14-Inch Indoor Pizza Oven stands out for its rapid preheating, reaching 850°F in just 15 minutes, and cooking a 14-inch pizza in only 3 minutes, making it ideal for those who want restaurant-quality results quickly. Unlike the Cuisinart Indoor Pizza Oven, which takes longer to preheat and offers a slightly lower maximum temperature, this model emphasizes speed without sacrificing versatility, thanks to multiple preset programs. However, its limited voltage range means it’s best suited for regions with 110V-120V outlets and may require some assembly. Perfect for busy home chefs who value quick turnaround, yet less ideal for owners in higher-voltage areas or those seeking plug-and-play simplicity without assembly.
Pros:- Fast preheating to 850°F in 15 minutes
- Cooks 14-inch pizzas in just 3 minutes
- Space-saving flip-up design for easy storage
- Multiple preset programs for baking different foods
Cons:- Limited to 110V-120V regions, restricting use elsewhere
- Requires some assembly or setup out of the box
- Potentially less durable with frequent use
Best for: Home cooks who prioritize rapid, high-temperature cooking and versatile preset options
Not ideal for: Users in regions with higher voltage supply or those seeking a fully plug-and-play experience
- Maximum Temperature:850°F
- Preheat Time:15 minutes
- Cooking Time:3 minutes for 14-inch pizzas
- Power:1800W
- Voltage:110V-120V
- Size:14 inches
Our verdict“This pick is ideal for those seeking a compact, fast, and versatile oven for frequent, high-temperature pizza cooking at home.”
Solo Stove Pi Prime Propane Pizza Oven
The Solo Stove Pi Prime offers exceptional portability and outdoor cooking capabilities, preheating in just 15 minutes and cooking pizzas in an astonishing 90 seconds, thanks to its powerful dome heating and durable stainless steel build. Compared with the Chefman Indoor Pizza Oven, which is more suited for indoor use and has a slower preheat time, the Pi Prime excels in outdoor environments where quick, high-quality results are desired. Its wide opening allows for easy monitoring, but it lacks a timer function, and outdoor use limits its versatility for everyday indoor baking. This model is perfect for outdoor gatherings or camping trips but isn’t a good fit for indoor kitchens or regions without propane access.
Pros:- Preheats in 15 minutes, ready for cooking
- Cooks pizzas in just 90 seconds for efficiency
- Durable stainless steel construction for outdoor durability
- Wide opening for easy monitoring and placement
Cons:- No timer function, requiring manual oversight
- Limited to outdoor use, restricting placement options
- Price may be higher than indoor options
Best for: Outdoor enthusiasts and hosts who want quick, restaurant-quality pizza on the go
Not ideal for: Indoor users with limited outdoor space or those without propane access
- Heating Method:Conduction
- Fuel Type:Propane
- Size:21 x 16 inches
- Item Dimensions:20.5″D x 20.5″W x 15.13″H
- Materials & Care:Stainless Steel
- Additional Features:Cordierite Pizza Stone, Panoramic Opening
Our verdict“This outdoor propane oven is perfect for quick, high-quality pizzas outside, especially for gatherings or camping, but not suited for indoor kitchens.”
12-inch Electric Pizza Oven Indoor Countertop Pizza Maker (Black)
The 12-inch Electric Pizza Oven offers a quick heating capability up to 800°F, making it suitable for achieving crisp crusts similar to traditional wood-fired pizzas. Its adjustable upper and lower temperature controls provide flexibility for different styles, and the ceramic cooking plate ensures even heat distribution. Compared to larger models like the BIG HORN, this unit is more compact but limited to 12-inch pizzas, which might be a drawback for larger appetites. Its bulkiness could be a concern in small kitchens, and detailed power consumption info is absent. This model suits small households or apartment dwellers who want a dedicated indoor pizza oven but may not be the best for frequent large batch cooking.
Pros:- Heats quickly up to 800°F for crispy crusts
- Adjustable temperature controls for customization
- Includes pizza baking tools for convenience
- Ceramic plate ensures even heat distribution
Cons:- Limited to 12-inch pizzas, restricting size
- Potentially bulky for tight spaces
- Lack of detailed power info may concern some users
Best for: Small households or apartment dwellers needing a compact, high-temperature pizza oven
Not ideal for: Users who regularly cook for large groups or need to bake bigger pizzas
- Size:12 inches
- Temperature:up to 800°F
- Material:Ceramic
Our verdict“This oven caters well to small spaces and quick, high-temperature pizzas but isn’t suited for larger quantities or bigger pizzas.”
Cuisinart Indoor Pizza Oven – Bake 12” Pizzas in Minutes – Portable Countertop Pizza Oven – Pomodoro Red Stainless Steel
The Cuisinart Indoor Pizza Oven effectively combines speed and versatility, baking 12-inch pizzas in just 5 minutes across a temperature range of 350°F to 700°F. Its large viewing window and interior light make monitoring straightforward, and the included pizza kit adds convenience. When compared with the Chefman model, which also offers quick results, the Cuisinart’s broader temperature range allows for more styles, though its preheat time can extend up to 30 minutes. Its limited to 12-inch pizzas but offers a complete pizza-making experience in a stylish package, though it does require significant counter space. This is ideal for casual home pizza nights and hobby bakers but less so for high-volume or professional use.
Pros:- Bakes 12-inch pizzas in just 5 minutes
- Wide temperature range for different styles
- Includes complete pizza kit (stone, peel, pan)
- Large viewing window with interior light
Cons:- Preheating can take up to 30 minutes
- Limited to 12-inch pizzas
- Requires ample counter space
Best for: Home cooks seeking a versatile, stylish, and easy-to-use indoor pizza oven
Not ideal for: Users needing large capacity or those with limited counter space
- Maximum Pizza Size:12 inches
- Temperature Range:350°F – 700°F
- Preheat Time:Up to 30 minutes
Our verdict“A versatile and stylish option for casual pizza lovers who want quick, varied results at home, though space and preheat time are considerations.”
Chefman Indoor Pizza Oven – Makes 12 Inch Pizzas in Minutes, Heats up to 800°F, Countertop Electric Pizza Maker with Touchscreen Presets, Pizza Stone and Peel Included
The Chefman Indoor Pizza Oven combines high heat with touchscreen presets, making it easy to achieve professional-style pizzas in minutes. Capable of reaching 800°F, it’s comparable to the BIG HORN in temperature but offers more user-friendly controls through its digital interface. It includes a pizza stone and peel, simplifying the process for novices and experienced cooks alike. Compared to the Cuisinart model, this oven heats faster and offers more precise control, but it’s limited to 12-inch pizzas and requires a standard 120V outlet. Its sleek design makes it suitable for small kitchens, though the lack of user reviews on durability over time warrants caution. This is perfect for tech-savvy users wanting quick, customizable results but less so for those needing larger capacity or outdoor use.
Pros:- Heats rapidly up to 800°F for restaurant-quality pies
- Touchscreen presets simplify operation
- Includes pizza stone and peel for ease of use
- Compact, stylish design fits small kitchens
Cons:- Limited to 12-inch pizzas
- No info on long-term durability
- Requires standard 120V power outlet
Best for: Tech-savvy home cooks who want fast, customizable pizza results with modern controls
Not ideal for: Users who need larger capacity or are looking for outdoor options
- Power:1700 Watts
- Voltage:120V
- Temperature Range:300-800°F
- Included Components:Cookbook, Pizza Peel, Pizza Stone
Our verdict“A quick, tech-friendly pizza oven ideal for those who value speed and modern features in a compact design, but limited in size capacity.”
13-in-1 Countertop Pizza Oven with 90-Second 12-Inch Pizza, Up to 850°F, 6 Presets & Bake Modes, PID Control, Expert Mode, Silver
This oven stands out for its impressive speed, capable of baking a 12-inch pizza in just 90 seconds at temperatures up to 850°F, making it ideal for replicating New York-style pies quickly. Compared with the Piezano XL, which offers slightly lower maximum heat and a larger size, this model’s rapid baking and array of presets and modes give it a distinct edge in versatility. The inclusion of a pizza stone, peel, and baking pan enhances the convenience, though the high temperature requires careful handling and preheating. Its compact size suits serious home cooks who want quick, authentic results without sacrificing variety or control.
Pros:- Fast baking with 90-second pizza capability
- Multiple presets and bake modes for versatility
- Includes a complete kit with pizza stone, peel, and pan
- Interior light and top window for monitoring
Cons:- Limited to 12-inch pizzas, not suitable for larger sizes
- High temperature operation requires caution and preheating
Best for: Home chefs seeking a fast, adaptable oven that can produce authentic New York-style crusts with minimal fuss.
Not ideal for: Users who prefer larger pizzas or need an oven with more capacity for multiple pies at once.
- Power:1700W
- Temperature:Up to 850°F
- Pizza Size:12 inches
- Presets:6
- Bake Modes:6
- Included Accessories:Pizza stone, pizza peel, baking pan, recipe guide
Our verdict“This oven is perfect for home cooks who prioritize speed and variety in making authentic New York-style pizzas.”
Electric Pizza Oven – 6 Programs, Max 840°F, Suitable for 12 inch Pizzas, 5-in-1 Multifunction with Pizza Stone and Peel
This model offers a slightly lower maximum temperature at 840°F but compensates with 6 preset programs tailored for different pizza styles, including New York, making it a flexible choice for varied tastes. Unlike the 13-in-1 oven, which emphasizes speed and presets, this oven’s multiple functions—baking, roasting, warming, and grilling—broaden its use, although the interface may feel complex for some. The included pizza stone and peel support authentic, high-quality pies, but the limited size (up to 12 inches) and potential complexity mean it’s best for those comfortable with multi-function appliances and precise control.
Pros:- Heats quickly to 840°F for authentic stone-baked pizzas
- Multiple preset programs for different styles
- Includes pizza stone and peel for convenient pizza making
- Compact design fits well on countertops
Cons:- Limited to 12-inch pizzas, not suitable for larger sizes
- Control interface may be complex for some users
- High temperature requires careful handling
Best for: Home cooks who want a multifunctional oven capable of handling different cooking styles, including authentic pizza baking.
Not ideal for: Beginners or those seeking a dedicated pizza oven with straightforward operation and maximum heat for traditional pies.
- Maximum Temperature:840°F
- Cooking Time:90 seconds for pizza
- Programs:6 preset programs
- Temperature Range:80°C to 450°C
- Insulation:Double insulation
- Included Components:Pizza oven, pizza peel, pizza stone, user manual
Our verdict“This oven suits experienced home cooks who value multifunctionality and authentic results with moderate size limitations.”
Piezano XL 14″ Electric Pizza Oven Indoor Countertop Pizza Maker
The Piezano XL excels at producing pizzeria-quality crusts thanks to its larger 14-inch size and a maximum temperature of 800°F, slightly below the other two models, but its natural ceramic stone ensures excellent heat retention and even baking. Unlike the smaller, more feature-heavy ovens, its straightforward controls and removable stone make it easier to handle and clean, though it takes longer to preheat and requires a 3-prong outlet. This makes it well-suited for enthusiasts who want sizable, crispy pies with minimal complexity, but less ideal for those seeking rapid baking or multiple small pizzas at once.
Pros:- Heats up to 800°F for crispy, pizzeria-quality crusts
- Removable ceramic stone for easy cleaning
- Large 14-inch size accommodates bigger pizzas
- Adjustable heat controls for precise baking
Cons:- Preheating takes longer compared to smaller ovens
- Requires a 3-prong power outlet
- Limited to indoor countertop use
Best for: Home pizza lovers who prioritize larger, authentic pizzeria-style pies with straightforward operation and easy maintenance.
Not ideal for: Small kitchens or users who need quick, high-temperature baking for multiple pizzas in rapid succession.
- Size:14 inches
- Maximum Temperature:800°F
- Power:Electric
- Removable Stone:Yes
- Heat Controls:Adjustable top and bottom
- Display:Built-in thermometer
Our verdict“This oven is ideal for those who want large, high-quality pizzas with straightforward operation and don’t mind preheating time.”
How We Picked
These pizza ovens were selected based on their ability to reach high temperatures (around 800°F or more), which is critical for authentic New York-style crusts. We prioritized models with sufficient cooking capacity to produce full-sized slices, as well as those with even heat distribution for consistent results. Usability features such as preset programs, intuitive controls, and included accessories like pizza stones influence ease of use. Durability, build quality, and value for money also played key roles in the rankings, ensuring each pick offers a distinct balance of performance and practicality for different types of buyers.Factors to Consider When Choosing Pizza Oven For New York Style
Choosing the right pizza oven for New York style involves considering several factors beyond just temperature. These considerations help ensure your investment aligns with your cooking style, space, and budget, making the process more enjoyable and consistent.Temperature and Heat Retention
Reaching and maintaining temperatures around 800-850°F is vital for creating that characteristic crispy crust and quick cooking times typical of New York slices. Look for ovens with high maximum temperatures and good heat retention, which prevent hot spots and uneven cooking. Cheaper models may struggle to sustain these temperatures, resulting in less authentic results. Balancing power and insulation is key to achieving restaurant-quality crusts at home.
Size and Capacity
Deciding between a compact countertop model and a larger, more traditional oven depends on your available space and how many slices you want to produce at once. Larger ovens allow for full-sized, foldable slices, but require more counter space and can be heavier. Smaller models are more portable and easier to store, yet might limit you to smaller pizzas or fewer slices per batch. Consider your typical pizza size and storage options before choosing.
Ease of Use and Controls
Features like preset modes, digital timers, and PID controls can streamline the cooking process, especially if you’re aiming for consistent results. However, more advanced controls often come at a higher price and may require learning curves. For beginners, models with simple interfaces and clear instructions tend to be more forgiving, reducing the chances of under or overcooking your slices. Think about your comfort level with technology when selecting.
Accessories and Maintenance
Many pizza ovens include essential accessories like pizza stones, peels, or covers, which can enhance your cooking experience. Durable materials like stainless steel and easy-to-clean surfaces reduce maintenance hassle. Be aware that some models may require special cleaning routines or replacement parts that add to long-term costs. Compatibility with common pizza accessories can also influence your overall satisfaction.
Price and Longevity
Prices can range from budget-friendly options to premium models with advanced features. While investing more often yields better heat performance and durability, it’s important to match your budget with your expectations. Cheaper ovens might not sustain high temperatures or last as long, leading to frustration or additional replacement costs. Conversely, premium models offer superior results but may be overkill for casual cooks. Consider how often you’ll use the oven and your desired level of authenticity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a regular outdoor grill to make New York style pizza?
Yes, many outdoor grills can reach high enough temperatures and, with the right accessories like a pizza stone, can produce crispy, authentic New York-style slices. However, achieving consistent results can be tricky since grills often have uneven heat distribution and lack precise temperature controls. For more reliable cooking and better control over heat, dedicated pizza ovens are generally a better choice, especially if you plan to make pizza regularly.
Is a high-temperature oven necessary for authentic New York pizza?
Absolutely. Authentic New York pizza is characterized by a thin, crispy crust that develops quickly under intense heat—around 800-850°F. Lower temperature ovens tend to produce a softer, less crispy crust and require longer cooking times, which can compromise the classic texture and flavor. Investing in an oven capable of reaching these high temperatures is key to replicating pizzeria-quality results at home.
Should I buy an indoor or outdoor pizza oven for New York style pizza?
Indoor ovens are more convenient for year-round use and typically fit into standard kitchen spaces, but they often have lower maximum temperatures and limited capacity. Outdoor ovens, especially portable or built-in models, can reach higher temperatures and accommodate larger pizzas, making them ideal for authentic New York slices. Your choice depends on your available space, climate, and how often you plan to cook pizza. For true authenticity, outdoor options often have the edge due to higher heat capabilities.
How important are accessories like pizza stones and peels?
Accessories such as pizza stones and peels significantly impact the cooking process and final result. A good pizza stone helps distribute heat evenly and creates the crispy crust characteristic of New York pizza. A sturdy peel makes transferring pizzas in and out of the oven safer and easier. Many ovens include these accessories, but ensuring compatibility and quality can enhance your overall experience. Investing in durable, well-made accessories is often worthwhile for consistent, professional-like results.
Is it worth paying more for a high-end pizza oven?
Higher-end models generally offer higher maximum temperatures, better heat retention, and more precise controls, which directly translate into more authentic and consistent results. They are usually more durable and easier to operate, making them a worthwhile investment for frequent pizza makers. However, if you only make pizza occasionally or are just starting out, a mid-range or budget model might suffice without sacrificing too much quality. Consider your usage frequency and desired results when evaluating value.
Conclusion
For casual home cooks or those just starting out, a reliable mid-range model like the Cuisinart Indoor Pizza Oven provides good performance without overwhelming complexity. If you’re seeking the best overall experience and authentic results, the BIG HORN 14-Inch Indoor Pizza Oven stands out as the top pick. Outdoor enthusiasts or serious hobbyists should consider high-temperature, larger-capacity options like the Solo Stove Pi Prime or premium models for consistent professional-quality slices. Budget-conscious buyers will find solid value in models with essential features, while dedicated pizza lovers aiming for perfection might prioritize premium features and build quality.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
